How do you know when a new heating and cooling system is right for you?

What should you consider when making that decision?

In any system’s life-cycle, there comes a point where you need to decide whether it’s fiscally and practically feasible to continue maintaining and repairing an aging, degrading system. Maybe you are 10 years into the unit’s 15-year life expectancy, but due to maintenance neglect the system is functioning poorly and inefficiently.
Your system may also not be able to meet your current cooling and heating needs. You need to consider whether it is worth suffering another year or two when a new, efficient system can provide you with consistent cooling and heating comfort and pay itself off in two to three years. And, speaking of cost, remember, you could save up to 60% on your energy bills with a newer, higher efficiency system.
In some cases even if your air conditioner is only a few years old, it could be very inefficient by today’s energy efficiency standards. Installing a newer, higher efficiency heating and cooling system can actually pay for itself in energy savings within a fairly short time.
You might want to check what your system’s SEER, AFUE and HSPF ratings are.
SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) is the cooling efficiency of your air conditioner. It tells you how efficiently your unit uses electricity. In general, the higher the SEER rating, the less electricity your unit will use to cool your home. The typical SEER rating of a/c units made before 1992 is about 6.0. In 1992, the minimum cooling efficiency for newly built homes was set at 10.0 SEER. High-efficiency units have a SEER of at least 13.0 now, and the maximum available is 21.
AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency) is the standard measurement of efficiency for gas and oil-fired furnaces. Given in percentages, this number tells you how much of your fuel is used to heat your home and how much fuel is wasted. The higher the AFUE rating, the greater the efficiency. AFUE ratings range from the minimum industry requirement of 78% up to 95%. If you have an older furnace with an AFUE of approximately 60%, you could save up to 40% on your heating bills by replacing it with a new high efficiency furnace. The cost to replace your old, inefficient furnace is paid back through lower utility bills.
HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor) is the efficiency measurement used to gauge the efficiency of the heating mode of heat pumps. The higher the number, the greater the efficiency and cost-savings. The current range for HSPF is from 6.8 to 9.5. You will probably see the higher cost of a high efficiency air conditioner or heat pump paid back through lower utility bills in a few short years.

Heat Pumps

A heat pump runs totally on electricity and provides heating in the winter and cooling in the summer by pumping or transferring heat rather than producing heat which results in potentially significant energy efficiency/savings. In the summer, it operates like a standard air conditioner, with refrigerant (a special liquid) absorbing heat from the air inside your home and the compressor pumping it outside. In the winter, the process is reversed. The heat pump absorbs heat from the air outdoors and the compressor pumps it inside. Absorbing heat from winter air may sound a little strange, but even on the coldest days of winter, heat is always present in the outside air.
And unlike fossil fuel systems-such as natural gas, oil or propane furnaces heat pumps use no combustion process in their operation. They create no polluting by-products and, therefore, leave your home cleaner and fresher. In addition, electric heat pumps do not create any potential for carbon monoxide poisoning.
To provide the greatest degree of efficiency and comfort, a heat pump must be the correct size. Undersizing the unit can decrease the level of comfort provided, and oversizing wastes energy and can cause poor indoor humidity control. The heat provided by a properly sized and installed heat pump is a warm, steady, consistent heat without the hot and cold spots and temperature extremes that you can experience with other types of heating systems.
Choose a heat pump with a higher SEER rating for lower operation cost

Some advantages include:

It is considered the most energy efficient electric HVAC system.

Maintains a more consistent comfort level because the heat temperature is lower than in conventional heating systems.

It provides a more even temperature.

There is no pilot light or vent to worry about.

No seasonal change over between systems.

Only one fuel bill.

Some disadvantages include:

When the outside temperature falls below 32 degrees, a heat pump might not be able to keep up with heating the house and it becomes less efficient. However, typically, heat pumps come with electrical backup heaters to assist during such cold temperatures.

Some people find the air provided by the heat pump “cold” in the winter months although this air is actually as warm as 105 degrees F.

Dual Fuel Systems

Duel Fuel system combines a heat pump with a back up natural gas or propane furnace for heat when outside temperatures are low enough to make it economical. The heat pump provides the summer cooling and the primary winter heating, and the furnace serves as a back-up when the outside air temperature drops below 40­° F. This dual fuel system enables you to benefit from the lowest possible heating and cooling costs.
A dual-fuel unit costs more than conventional heating and cooling systems because you’re getting essentially two systems in one. But the amount you’ll save in the next two to three years from lower heating costs will probably more than make up the difference you’ll spend on a dual fuel system.

Ductless System or Mini-Split

Ductless split-system air-conditioners are used for houses with non-ducted distribution systems (where extending or installing ductwork is not feasible), and for additions such as bonus rooms, enclosed patios, etc.
Ductless split-system air-conditioners combine the zoning flexibility of a conventional room unit (a single air-conditioner installed through a wall or a window frame) with the whole house cooling potential of central systems. Like central systems, they have two main components: a compressor/condenser, as well as an air- handling unit, which contains an evaporator and a fan. Some units operate as heat pumps and provide both summer cooling and winter heating.
The compressor and condenser are housed as one unit and located outdoors. The quiet fan/evaporator unit is indoors, located in the area to be cooled or heated. A conduit, which houses the power cable, refrigerant tubing, suction tubing, and condensate drain, links the outdoor and indoor units.

Some advantages include:

Provides zone cooling which saves energy since only the rooms that are occupied need to be cooled or heated.

Quiet operation

Versatility in zoning and design

Eliminate the loss of cool air as it passes through the ductwork

If purchasing an air conditioner for the whole house is not affordable, buying the system one zone at a time is an ideal option.

Variable speed high efficiency fans are also available

Some disadvantages include:

Higher initial cost

Not everyone likes the appearance of the air-handling unit. While less obtrusive than a window unit, they seldom have the built-in look of a central system.

Packaged Units

A packaged unit contains the same components you find in a typical split system. However, all components are located in one unit. Just like other systems, you have a variety of efficiency levels and air handling options to select from. A package unit is typically installed either beside, on top of the home, or sometimes in the attic.

Some advantages include:

Easier to install – only requires wiring and ductwork to be installed

When the crawl space is limited in height and space

Can be installed on top of flat roofs with ductwork installed through the roof

Some disadvantages include:

Very difficult to add humidifiers, dehumidifiers, uv lights, filtration systems

High Pressure (Unico)

For homeowners without forced-air HVAC systems, adding central air conditioning and/or heating ducts can be a daunting task. Installation can require adding unsightly box chases or removing large sections of walls, floors, or ceilings, making it expensive and difficult. In historic homes, traditional forced-air systems may also mar original architectural features, such as plaster moldings.
For these homes, high-velocity heating and cooling systems or, also known as, high-pressure systems can offer an easier solution. These systems use small-diameter ducts that can be more easily threaded through floor, ceiling, and wall cavities and around common obstructions. This minimizes necessary alterations, thereby reducing the installed cost of the system.
High-velocity systems operate by using a special fan coil and air-handling unit that generates high-pressure air that is forced through the small-diameter ducts. The main supply trunk is composed of either a rectangular or a round duct that supplies air to flexible, insulated, 2-inch-diameter plastic feeder ducts. Installation of thermostats and automated climate-control systems is the same as with more traditional ductwork.

Some advantages include:

Suitability for retrofits

Unico and Spacepak systems claim to improve dehumidification (reduce moisture by over 30% versus conventional systems), energy efficiency, and room air mixing over standard air-delivery duct systems.

Can be installed on top of flat roofs with ductwork installed through the roof

Some disadvantages include:

Higher cost

Only comes as a heat pump, electric heat or straight air conditioner

Increased noise compared with conventional systems. However, to address this issue, manufacturers have added various sound-reducing features.

High-velocity systems have lower efficiency in terms of SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) and HSPF (Heating Seasonal Performance Factor) than standard ducted systems.

Gas Furnaces

The heat is supplied by the burning of natural gas or propane. A mixture of gas and air flows into the burner and is ignited by the pilot. Combustion occurs, and warm air from the burner flame rises to fill a chamber known as a heat exchanger. The heat exchanger becomes hot. Air passing around the heat exchanger absorbs that warmth, continues into the air ducts and the heat is distributed through the house. The by-products of combustion pass upward through a venting system and escape through a vent in the roof or the wall.
There are three main types of gas furnaces. Their ratings are based on AFUE, Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency, which is the standard measurement of efficiency for gas and oil-fired furnaces. Given in percentages, this number tells you how much of your fuel is used to heat your home and how much fuel is wasted. The higher the AFUE rating, the greater the efficiency. AFUE ratings range from the minimum industry requirement of 78% up to 95%. If you have an older furnace with an AFUE of approximately 60%, you could save up to 40% on your heating bills by replacing it with a new high efficiency furnace. The cost to replace your old, inefficient furnace is paid back through lower utility bills.

Some advantages include:

Could be vented through the wall

95% maximum efficiency

Some disadvantages include:

Produces very dry air